The classic. The baseline. The “why is this so good?” cup.
This is the one that started it all—the original, no-frills, crowd-pleasing peanut butter cup that doesn’t need a gimmick because it already understands the assignment.
Thick milk chocolate. Creamy peanut butter. Oversized in a way that feels both unnecessary and absolutely correct.
If you’re new here, start with The OG. If you’re not new here… you already know.
- Traditional milk chocolate peanut butter cup
- One of the largest peanut butter cups out there
- Classic flavor, big satisfying bite
- Perfect for gifting (or not sharing)
- Made by CB Stuffer
What It Is
A 5.6 oz traditional milk chocolate peanut butter cup—simple, iconic, and intentionally oversized.
This is the base flavor in the lineup and the one everything else is built around.
Net weight: 5.6 oz
Ingredients & Allergens
Ingredient and allergen information will be added as soon as it’s available from the maker.
Because this is a milk chocolate peanut butter cup, it likely contains common allergens such as milk, peanuts, and soy. If you have dietary or allergy concerns, please wait for the full ingredient list or reach out before purchasing.
How to Enjoy It
- Eat straight from the wrapper like a responsible adult with priorities
- Slice into wedges for sharing (optional)
- Pair with coffee, milk, or a “treat yourself” moment
- Chill for a firmer bite or warm slightly for extra gooey
FAQ
How big is “big”?
This cup is 5.6 oz—much larger than a standard peanut butter cup.
Is this the same as a regular peanut butter cup flavor?
Yes—classic milk chocolate + peanut butter, just bigger and more satisfying.
Do you have the ingredient list yet?
Not yet. We’ll update the listing as soon as the maker provides the confirmed details.
Is this meant to be shared?
It can be, but it’s also perfectly valid as a solo situation.
How should I store it?
Room temperature is great—just keep it away from heat.
Is this the best “first cup” to try?
Yes. If you want the classic experience before exploring flavors, The OG is the move.
