Sally's Kitchen · Homemade Coffee Syrup
Butterscotch Syrup for Coffee
Butter, brown sugar and a little smoked salt. The flavor you can never find on the café board, made in two small pans.
You know the one. You scan the café menu for butterscotch and find caramel, caramel, and one more caramel. This syrup fixes that, and it turns a mug of Butterscotch Flavored Coffee into something you would happily pay café prices for, minus the line and the lid.
It is a cooked syrup, but it is a forgiving one. You are looking for two things: a caramel-colored foam on the butter and brown sugar, and a slow, steady pour when the two pans meet. Once you have seen it, you will know it every time.
One jar makes a lot of lattes, and it is not only for coffee. Pancakes, yogurt, ice cream and a mug of black tea are all fair game (details below).
Why You'll Love It
- Real butter and brown sugar, so it tastes like butterscotch instead of "sweet with a flavor name."
- Two pans, one whisk, and a fine mesh sieve is optional. You do not need a candy thermometer.
- Forgiving and adjustable: start with 1 Tbsp in a latte, work up to 3 if you want it dessert-level.
- Keeps in the fridge for up to 2 weeks, so Tuesday's you is covered.
Yield
About 1½ cups
Time
About 20 min + cooling
Vibe
Buttery & cozy
The Coffee That Makes This Work
Butterscotch Flavored Coffee is a smooth medium roast Brazilian bean with butterscotch flavor applied after roasting, so the cup already leans buttery before the syrup shows up. The syrup then adds the real brown sugar and butter depth on top, which is why the two together taste like one thing instead of two. You could use another medium roast, but this is the one we reach for with this syrup.
Shop Butterscotch Flavored Coffee →Available in whole bean, ground, and single-serve cups. Fresh roasted to order, every time.
Butterscotch Syrup Ingredients
Sugar water (pan 1)
- 1 cup water
- 1 cup granulated sugar
Butterscotch base (pan 2)
- 2 Tbsp water
- 2 Tbsp butter
- ½ tsp smoked salt
- ¼ cup brown sugar
Off the heat
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
How to Make It
- Make the sugar water. Combine the sugar and 1 cup water in a small saucepan over medium heat. Stir until the sugar has dissolved and the liquid looks clear, with no grains left on the spoon. Set it aside.
- Start the butterscotch. In a second pan, combine the 2 Tbsp water, butter, smoked salt and brown sugar over low heat. Cook until a caramel-colored foam forms, and pull it off the heat if it starts to smell sharp or burnt. Why it works: the butter and brown sugar toast together here, and that is where the butterscotch flavor comes from.
- Bring the pans together. Whisking as you go, pour the sugar water from pan 1 into pan 2 slowly. It usually bubbles up, so use a pan with some headroom. Keep whisking until it is fully combined. Why it works: a slow pour keeps the bubbling under control and helps everything blend smoothly.
- Finish and cool. Take the pan off the heat, stir in the vanilla, and let the syrup cool. Pour it into a jar with a lid and keep it in the fridge for up to 2 weeks. Why it works: vanilla's aroma fades with heat, so it goes in last to keep the flavor you paid for.
Made this one? Butterscotch Flavored Coffee is available whole bean, ground, and in single-serve cups, so however you make your coffee, it works. Fresh roasted to order, every time.
More recipes like this one are at The Menu, and more homemade syrups live in the Syrup Masterclass.
Storage & Shelf Life
Keep the cooled syrup in a jar with a lid in the fridge. It keeps for up to 2 weeks.
The butter can firm up slightly in the cold, which is normal. Warm the syrup a little and stir before you use it, and it comes right back.
Ways to Use Butterscotch Syrup
- Hot coffee: a spoonful stirred into the bottom of the mug before you brew over it.
- Iced coffee and cold brew: warm the syrup first so it stirs in evenly, then pour over ice.
- Lattes: see the butterscotch latte below.
- Black tea: a spoonful in a strong mug with a splash of milk.
- Pancakes and waffles: a warm drizzle instead of maple.
- Yogurt and oatmeal: stirred in or swirled on top.
- Ice cream and desserts: over vanilla ice cream, bread pudding, or a plain cheesecake.
Featured Drink: The Butterscotch Latte
For one mug
- 2 Tbsp butterscotch syrup
- 2 oz brewed espresso, or 4 oz strong brewed Butterscotch Flavored Coffee
- 6 oz milk of choice
Hot
- Put the syrup in the bottom of your mug and brew the coffee directly over it. Stir to combine.
- Warm and froth the milk to the texture you like, then pour it over the coffee.
Iced
- Fill a tumbler about two-thirds with ice and pour the milk over it.
- Stir the syrup into the brewed coffee, then pour it over the milk.
Make It Yours
- The sweetness dial: 1 Tbsp is subtle, 2 Tbsp is the standard latte, 3 Tbsp is dessert.
- Dairy-free: use your favorite dairy-free milk. The syrup itself contains butter.
- No smoked salt: regular salt works, just start with a little less and taste. You will lose the faint smoky edge.
- Cold foam: a spoonful of syrup whipped into cream and milk makes a quick topper.
Permission slip: store-bought butterscotch syrup is also fine. We simply think the homemade one makes Tuesday feel like the weekend.
Not Quite Right? Here's the Fix
Want to geek out?
- Butterscotch is usually built on brown sugar and butter, while a basic caramel is usually cooked from white sugar. That is why this one tastes rounder and more buttery.
- The foam you are watching for is butter and brown sugar cooking together. The deeper the color, the stronger the toasted flavor, until it tips into bitter.
- The extra sugar water makes the finished product a pourable syrup rather than a thick sauce.
Butterscotch Syrup FAQ
How do you make butterscotch syrup for coffee?
Dissolve sugar in water in one pan. In a second pan, cook butter, brown sugar, water and smoked salt until a caramel-colored foam forms. Whisk the sugar water into the second pan slowly, stir in vanilla off the heat, and let it cool.
How long does homemade butterscotch syrup last?
Up to 2 weeks in a lidded jar in the fridge. The butter may firm up when cold, so warm the syrup a little and stir before using.
Is butterscotch syrup the same as caramel syrup?
Not quite. Butterscotch is usually made with brown sugar and butter, which gives it a rounder, more buttery flavor. Caramel syrup is usually cooked from white sugar.
How much butterscotch syrup goes in a latte?
2 Tbsp is a good starting point for a standard 6 oz milk latte. Use 1 Tbsp for a lighter sweetness or up to 3 Tbsp for a dessert-style drink.
What can I use instead of smoked salt?
Regular fine salt works. Start with a little less than the recipe calls for and taste, since you will lose the faint smoky edge.
